Supplementary Exercise 4.73 of IPS7e ------------------------------------ Two scales for measuring weight. For an item with true weight of 2 g, the scales give results: X with mean 2.000 g and std.dev. 0.002 g, Y with mean 2.001 g and std.dev. 0.001 g. Also, X and Y are independent. Note that in the terminology to be introduced in Session 5, the estimate Y is more precise than X, but less accurate. (a) Z = Y-X. EZ = EY-EX = 2.001-2.000 = 0.001 g VarZ = VarY+VarX = 0.002^2 + 0.001^2 = 0.000005 g^2 sdZ = sqrt(VarZ) = 0.00224 g (b) Z = (X+Y)/2 EZ = (EX+EY)/2 = (2.000+2.001)/2 = 2.0005 g VarZ = 0.5^2 *(VarX+VarY) = 0.25*(0.002^2 + 0.001^2) = 0.00000125 g^2 sdZ = sqrt(VarZ) = 0.00112 g Therefore the average, Z, is more variable than Y, but its mean is closer to the true value. In the above terminology, we could say Z is more accurate than Y, but less precise.