Extra Exercise 17 ----------------- (a) The degrees of freedom are 3-1=2 for the groups and 30-1=29 for total, as expected. It is also seen that the Mean Square values are calculated by dividing the Sum of Squares by the df. Finally, F equals the ratio between the two Mean Square values. (b) When the blue population mean goes from 19.99 to 20, the P-value switches from P<0.05 to P>0.05 as F decreases from 3.367 to 3.333. The 95%-percentile of the F(2,27) distribution was determined (in Minitab) to be 3.354, in-between those two values, as expected. (c) When moving one group away from the others, the between-group variation increases. This is because the between-group variation is computed from the group means as the sum of squared deviations from the overall mean. As the numerator of the F-statistic is a constant times this between-group variation, the F-statistic increases and eventually becomes significant when the groups get far apart. Intuitively, the larger group differences, the more indicative the data are of group (population) means being unequal. (d) When increasing the variation within the groups the F-statistic decreases and the P-value increases. Mathematically, the F-statistic is computed as a ratio with the estimated within-group variation in the denominator; thus it is no surprise that F decreases when the within-group variation increases. Intuitively, the more variation in the data (within the groups), the more difficult it should be to detect differences between groups. Note that the between-group variation is constant because the group means are unchanged. The F-test is one-tailed and the P-value includes only larger values, therefore a smaller value of F also implies a larger P-value.